There are some lies that we want to hear, we want to be told that we will be safe, that we are the good guys and that our enemies are afraid. This is the truth of human nature, we accept what we want to accept and so often believe what we are told to believe. It is a shame really that we are not more demanding of the truth, but in some cases we want to be lied to.
This topic came to me on a recent trip to the ‘Berlin Unterwelten‘ (Berlin Underworld, which by the way I would recommend to one and all as an excellent activity if ever you are in Berlin). I took the tour 3 which explores the bunkers built for the cold war, one of the disturbing things about the bomb shelters and nuclear bunkers is the sheer impossibility of their operation. What I mean by this is that we visited two bunkers that were constructed to protect Berliners from nuclear fallout as a result of nuclear war between Russia and the USA. At the time west Berlin had a population of 2 million people and the entire network of bunkers constructed could house a measly 0.8% of that. So considering all the men, women and children that would be excluded from the bunkers we can see that these bunkers should offer little hope. To add to this the maximum operation times of the two bunkers were 48 hours and 3 weeks respectively. In reality this would not protect the people from nuclear fallout but merely prolong the inevitable.
Even more astounding in this case were the published material on display, in these it depicts how to survive a nuclear blast, a man stands within sight of the mushroom cloud, he then proceeds to lie on the ground and cover his head with a brief case. This was serious advice provided to the German people on what to do if they saw a nuclear blast. I am sure that both the stories of insufficient bunkers and blatantly flawed survival tips were repeated in the US and Russia alike. It is the truth that these tales highlight which is truly revealing. When the population lives under constant threat, people desire to be told that everything will be alright, that the government will protect them and that even if the world would end tomorrow there would be a chance you could survive.
Living with the pressure of a great threat is hard, justifying doing mundane things like going to work or washing the dishes is difficult when the world as you know it could be over at any time, and so we lie. We lie to ourselves and we lie to each other. The governments world wide lie to their people and the world feels for a short time like a safer place.
I wonder though whether if the same scenario were to arise now, in the information age whether the propaganda would provide as much comfort. Or would the word spread amongst the masses that we aren’t safe, that the ship is sinking and the designers didn’t build enough life boats.
The question we need to ask ourselves is what do we want to be lied to about, every piece of history comes with a twisted view, that of the writer, the survivor, the victor or the victim. We generate a narrative that forms our view of the world, the stories we are told and the experiences we have form and shape this narrative. We incorporate our family histories and that of our nation. But the stories we accept as truth are never completely true. I am seeing the world through new eyes looking at the history of Berlin as told by Berlin. it is interesting to reconcile the slightly different views of the same events and to form and dissolve at the same time stereotypes of the wider world.
It is ok sometimes to be lied to, sometimes it is necessary and sometimes it is ok to accept those lies. I think that it is important however to recognise the lies we tell ourselves and the lies we accept so that we do not become blinded to the truth and stuck in our false beliefs. Always test the words you hear and search for the alternate point of view.
Best of luck in the New Year and may 2013 be filled with truth for us all.
Cheers,
Dan
